Israel’s Foreign Minister says Palestinians will not be forcibly deported from Gaza. But statements by other Israeli ministers, continuing settler violence in the occupied West Bank and delays in Gaza’s humanitarian reconstruction raise serious questions about Israel’s wider policy.
Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar has presented Israel’s position on Gaza as one that rejects forced deportation.
On September 9, 2026, Sa’ar said Israel was not planning to expel or deport Palestinians from Gaza against their will.
He added that Israel would not oppose Palestinians who voluntarily wished to leave if another country agreed to receive them.
But his statement must be examined alongside the positions of other senior members of the Israeli government.
Different messages from the same government
Defence Minister Israel Katz previously said plans to facilitate mass emigration from Gaza remained under discussion.
National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir also promoted a plan encouraging the departure of the vast majority of Gaza’s Palestinian population.
Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich has also supported encouraging Palestinians to leave.
These statements raise an important question: if forced displacement is not Israel’s policy, why have senior government ministers publicly promoted plans to encourage the departure of Gaza’s population?
The difference between forced deportation and so-called voluntary emigration is significant. Any assessment must examine whether Palestinians have a genuine choice, particularly when their homes and essential infrastructure have been destroyed and basic living conditions remain severely restricted.
Hamas disarmament cannot replace civilian protection
Sa’ar has repeatedly presented Hamas disarmament, demilitarisation and deradicalisation as central conditions for Gaza’s future.
However, the humanitarian needs of Gaza’s civilian population cannot be made secondary to political negotiations.
On November 9, the US-backed Board of Peace called on Israel to facilitate the entry of winter supplies, temporary shelter materials, sanitation equipment and drainage infrastructure.
The Board described the humanitarian response as insufficient after flooding affected displaced Palestinians.
This raises questions for Israel and the international body: why are essential shelter and infrastructure materials still facing delays when civilians are already living in damaged buildings and temporary shelters?
Settler violence in the occupied West Bank
The questions are not limited to Gaza.
On November 10, Palestinian officials reported that Israeli settlers attacked Palestinian citizens and international solidarity activists in Qusra, south of Nablus.
Reports described a female activist being beaten and kicked. The incident was also reported by Siasat.
The European Union has previously condemned settler violence in Qusra and reminded Israel of its obligation to protect Palestinians living under occupation.
The Israeli government cannot address the conflict only through statements about Hamas while leaving attacks against Palestinian civilians and activists without effective accountability.
Who controls the future of Gaza?
The Trump-backed Board of Peace is presented as a framework for stabilisation, governance and reconstruction.
But reconstruction is not simply a matter of money, infrastructure and international administration.
The central question is whether Palestinians will have meaningful authority over their land, political institutions, reconstruction priorities and future.
Any framework that discusses Gaza’s future without meaningful Palestinian participation risks reproducing external control rather than delivering self-determination.
Questions about funding, contracts, procurement and the distribution of reconstruction resources also require transparency. Public accountability is essential, especially when international bodies and powerful governments are involved.
The questions Israel must answer
Gideon Sa’ar’s statements deserve to be examined against the actions and public positions of the government he represents.
- If Israel rejects forced displacement, how does it address ministers promoting mass emigration?
- What concrete action is being taken to stop settler attacks against Palestinians?
- Why are essential humanitarian and winter supplies still delayed?
- Who will control Gaza’s reconstruction funds and major contracts?
- Will Palestinians have genuine authority over Gaza’s political future?
These are not questions that can be answered simply by repeating that Hamas must disarm.
Gaza’s civilians have rights that do not disappear because of the actions of an armed group. Palestinians in the occupied West Bank also have the right to protection from violence.
The future of Palestine must not be decided solely by governments and international powers. Palestinians themselves must have a meaningful voice in decisions about their land and future.
THE WORLD’S UPDATE — Standing with the oppressed. Speaking for the unheard. Seeking truth without fear.